2014 Solar Plan for Sidmouth: another application rejected

The debate about what to do about local production of energy continues…

The plans for a solar farm outside Sidbury was shelved earlier in the year:
Futures Forum: Solar Plan for Sidmouth: a second application stalls as subsidies are questioned…

A new application at a new site has also been rejected by the Town Council:

243
14/2423/MFUL
Sidbury Ward
CROWPITS SOLAR PARK LTD
LAND AT CROWPITS, COOMBE ESTATE, SIDBURY.

Installation of a 9.9MW photovoltaic park with associated infrastructure including inverter stations, transformers, substations, security fence and pole
mounted and fixed security cameras (EIA Development with accompanying statement).

Members were unable to support the application for the following reasons:

 Contrary to Policy EN1 – Developments affecting Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty: It was considered that the proposed development would create a significant and detrimental visual impact in the countryside within this important Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty.

 Policy EN14 – Development on High Quality Agricultural Land and Policy S5 Countryside Protection of the East Devon Local Plan; the proposed use of this site would result in the loss of viable agricultural land.

 It was suggested that another more suitable site should be found to accommodate such a development.

Note: Members further suggested that if this proposal was to be implemented, a bond be made between the Applicant and East Devon District Council to ensure that money is made available to reinstate the land at the end of this temporary use.

www.sidmouth.gov.uk/images/downloads/Meetings/planning/PL._MINS._19.11.14.pdf

More information at the CPRE website:
Crowpitts, Sidbury Solar PV park 9.9MW (47 acres) – awaiting decision | Protecting Devon & Planning Appplications

And the full application is here, although there is currently no access:

14/2423/MFUL | Installation of a 9.9MW photovoltaic park …
https://planning.eastdevon.gov.uk/online…/applicationDetails.do?…
14/2423/MFUL | Installation of a 9.9MW photovoltaic park with associated infrastructure including inverter stations, transformers, substations, security fence and …

And here is today’s piece from the Herald:

 

 

 

 

 

Latest local news & information in Sidmouth | Sidmouth Herald

There seems to be a lot of hostility to the notion of ‘solar farms’ in general:

Solar farms ‘blight on countryside’

 

Liz Truss said solar panels were taking up land that could be used for food production
Liz Truss said solar panels were taking up land that could be used for food production
First published Sunday 19 October 2014 in National News© by Press Association 2014

Large-scale solar farms are a “blight on the countryside”, Environment Secretary Liz Truss said as she announced plans to axe a taxpayer subsidy to farmers and landowners for the schemes.

Ms Truss said she was concerned that the “ugly” rows of solar panels were taking up land that could be used for food production.

The Environment Secretary said she would end grants worth £2 million a year available via her department from the European Union’s Common Agriculture Policy.

Ms Truss told the Mail on Sunday: ” I want Britain to lead the world in food and farming and to do that we need enough productive agricultural land. I’m very concerned that a lot of our land is being taken up with solar farms. We’ve already got 250 of them and we’ve got 10,000 football pitches worth of new solar farms in the pipeline.”

She said the solar farms are “ugly, a blight on the countryside” as she signalled the end of the £100 an acre grant.

“Food and farming is our number one manufacturing industry, the whole food chain represents £100 billion in our economy, and it is a real problem if we are using productive agricultural land for solar farms,” she said. “I’m not against them per se – they’re fine on commercial roofs and school roofs – but it’s a big problem if we are using land that can be used to grow crops, fruit and vegetables. We import two-thirds of our apples, and using more land for solar panels makes it harder to improve that.”

Earlier this month the Department for Energy and Climate Change (Decc) slashed its support for large-scale solar farms, with subsidies under the existing “renewables obligation” ending next April, two years before they are curtailed for other technologies.

Decc said the move was necessary as large-scale solar developments – which have caused some controversy because of their impact on the countryside – were growing faster than expected and would exceed the budget for subsidies by £40 million in the next two years.

Solar farms ‘blight on countryside’ (From This is The West Country)

 

 

What are the arguments for and against solar farms?

This blog has reported on the failures of planning applications for solar farms in the Sid Valley:
Futures Forum: Solar Plan for Sidmouth: another application rejectedRecently, the Environment Minister has shown her opposition to solar farms:
Eclipse of the solar farms: Environment Secretary Liz Truss tells farmers ‘no more handouts for ugly fields of glass…grow veg!’  | Daily Mail Online
Solar farms ‘blight on countryside’ | Daily Mail Online
BBC News – Solar farms are a blight on the landscape, says minister

… which means that there will be fewer government grants:
Defra solar farm subsidies for ‘blight on countryside’ to be cut | Western Daily Press

What is the reasoning behind this policy?

.
.
See more at: Futures Forum: What are the arguments for and against solar farms?
   
© Vision Group for Sidmouth 2006-2018