“For farming to deliver our collective net zero ambitions and continue climate smart farming we need targeted incentives in the tax system for farm businesses to pursue the net zero agenda.” [Tom Bradshaw: deputy president, National Farmers’ Union]
“A question for us here in East Devon is the extent to which the specific conditions of ‘rural England’ are being taken into account.”
Local councils are pushing for zero-net-carbon: Carbon Plan reveals how all Devon can achieve net-zero – News and Exeter welcomes Devon Carbon Plan but remains committed to Net Zero 2030 – Exeter City Council News
Central government have committed to do so by 2050: UK becomes first major economy to pass net zero emissions law – GOV.UK
There are serious misgivings about this, however: “Net Zero is a lie” – Vision Group for Sidmouth and “There is no such thing as zero carbon or even ‘net’ zero.” – Vision Group for Sidmouth
Nevertheless, whilst the various authorities are indeed pushing ahead, another question for us here in East Devon is the extent to which the specific conditions of ‘rural England’ are being taken into account.
This is from October last year and posed several awkward questions: “Rural at the heart of Net Zero” – Vision Group for Sidmouth
The government has just released a report on ‘net zero’ – the independent Mission Zero report: MISSION ZERO – Independent Review of Net Zero and Net Zero Review: UK could do more to reap economic benefits of green growth – GOV.UK
The NFU is generally ‘satisfied’ with the review, but it is asking for more ‘targeted incentives’:
For farming to deliver our collective net zero ambitions and continue climate smart farming we need targeted incentives in the tax system for farm businesses to pursue the net zero agenda.
Net Zero review – NFU responds to ‘Mission Zero’ report – NFUonline
The Rural Services Network has put together a full response to the review:
RURAL LENS REVIEW ON MISSION ZERO – INDEPENDENT REVIEW OF NET ZERO
The Rural Services Network has published its Rural Lens review of the Mission Zero – Independent review by Rt Hon Chris Skidmore MP which was released in January 2023.
Mission Zero, makes 129 recommendations covering areas including the greater role that business can be supported to play, making better use of infrastructure and delivering more energy efficient homes. Every one is designed to maximise economic investment, opportunities and jobs – all while working towards achieving legally binding targets to reach net zero carbon emissions by 2050.
Rural Services Network’s thoughts on Mission Zero Independent Review, Net Zero by Rt Hon Chris Skidmore MP:
- The rural context must be fully reflected in all of the policy considerations set out in the recommendations. Decisions, including in respect of implementation, must be fully rural proofed.
- The Land Use Framework must be fully integrated into the spatial planning system and NPPF. It must not focus just on land management issues related to environmental protection, farming, food production and biodiversity. It should take full account of the requirements that communities have for housing, economic activity, recreation, and community activities.
- It is not just about “Funds”. We have huge concerns about the plethora of different funding streams which are required to be ‘bid for’ – especially given the capacity of rural local authorities. Mainstream government funding support for local government has for decades, and remains, grossly unfair.
- It is paramount that trailblazer projects also cover rural and coastal areas, indeed they should cover different types of rural areas.
- In most rural areas public transport simply is not available to enable travel to work, education/training or to meet other transport needs. In fact, in very many rural areas across England there is little or no public transport. As a result, car ownership remains essential in rural areas (despite car ownership costs) – indeed many rural households will need to have 2 or 3 cars as household members will need to travel in different directions to work etc.
- The Government’s long awaited Bus Strategy for Rural Areas should be published as soon as possible. Rural public transport authorities need much more financial support from the Government to enable improvements in bus services. Very little financial support came the way of rural councils from the recent Bus Service Improvement Plan Funding.
- We feel the report, unfortunately, misses the mark when understanding the practicalities and the challenges of decarbonising rural and off-gas grid heat. In both residential and non-residential buildings.
- The recommendations do not consider the fact that fabric modifications, most certainly needed for older and less energy efficient housing, will increase the cost of installation for heat pumps, making them prohibitively expensive for rural home and business owners.
- We have long argued that the Government should adopt a ‘fabric-first’ strategy with increased funding available in rural areas (and elsewhere) to support measures such as home insulation and other energy efficiency measures.
- In pursuing a one-size-fits-all approach, we are disappointed that the Net Zero Review overlooks the role of alternative renewable fuels.
You can read the full Rural Lens Review by clicking on the link: https://rsnonline.org.uk/images/rural-lens/mission-zero-rural-lens-review.pdf
Rural Lens review on Mission Zero – Independent review of Net Zero – Rural Services Network